Welcome to 5991 Seneca St – Where Suburban Dreams Meet Cannonballs!
Tired of cramped spaces and taxes that make you cry into your cereal? Well, dry those tears, because this Elma gem is here to turn your “meh” into “HECK YES.”
This 2300+ sq ft stunner gives you room to roam, dance like no one’s watching, or finally start that indoor curling league (we won’t judge). Nestled on a 400’ deep lot—yes, we measured—it’s got more backyard than your in-laws have opinions.
Step inside and be wowed by hardwood floors, hardwood steps and slate stone steps. An open kitchen perfect for pretending you’re on a cooking show, and a sunken family room that says, “We don’t follow rules, we make our own levels.”
Need laundry on the first floor? Done. Big ol’ wood deck? Check. Want to make your friends jealous? Say hello to your inground pool complete with diving board, slide, and a cinder block pool house so legit it might just moonlight as a bunker. Just be sure to fill the pool with clean water first.
All this in the highly sought-after Iroquois School District, with low taxes so friendly they could be elected mayor.
So pack your floaties and bring your best cannonball form—5991 Seneca St isn’t just a house, it’s a lifestyle with splash zone included.
Showings begin this Sat 5/3 at 12 Noon and Open House from 1-3 PM same day.
Tired of cramped spaces and taxes that make you cry into your cereal? Well, dry those tears, because this Elma gem is here to turn your “meh” into “HECK YES.”
This 2300+ sq ft stunner gives you room to roam, dance like no one’s watching, or finally start that indoor curling league (we won’t judge). Nestled on a 400’ deep lot—yes, we measured—it’s got more backyard than your in-laws have opinions.
Step inside and be wowed by hardwood floors, hardwood steps and slate stone steps. An open kitchen perfect for pretending you’re on a cooking show, and a sunken family room that says, “We don’t follow rules, we make our own levels.”
Need laundry on the first floor? Done. Big ol’ wood deck? Check. Want to make your friends jealous? Say hello to your inground pool complete with diving board, slide, and a cinder block pool house so legit it might just moonlight as a bunker. Just be sure to fill the pool with clean water first.
All this in the highly sought-after Iroquois School District, with low taxes so friendly they could be elected mayor.
So pack your floaties and bring your best cannonball form—5991 Seneca St isn’t just a house, it’s a lifestyle with splash zone included.
Showings begin this Sat 5/3 at 12 Noon and Open House from 1-3 PM same day.
Property Details
Price:
$299,900
MLS #:
B1603006
Status:
Active
Beds:
3
Baths:
1
Address:
5991 Seneca Street
Type:
Single Family
Subtype:
SingleFamilyResidence
Subdivision:
Buffalo Crk Reservation
Neighborhood:
Elma-144200
City:
Elma
Listed Date:
Apr 29, 2025
State:
NY
Finished Sq Ft:
2,394
Total Sq Ft:
2,394
ZIP:
14059
Lot Size:
82,764 sqft / 1.36 acres (approx)
Year Built:
1956
See this Listing
Mortgage Calculator
Schools
School District:
Iroquois
Interior
Appliances
Appliances Negotiable, Gas Water Heater
Bathrooms
1 Full Bathroom
Fireplaces Total
1
Flooring
Hardwood, Laminate, Varies, Vinyl
Heating
Gas, Forced Air
Laundry Features
Main Level
Exterior
Architectural Style
Cape Cod, Two Story
Construction Materials
Aluminum Siding, Attic Crawl Hatchways Insulated, Brick, Vinyl Siding
Exterior Features
Blacktop Driveway, Deck, Pool
Other Structures
Pool House
Parking Features
No Garage
Roof
Asphalt, Shingle
Financial
Taxes
$4,706
Map
Community
- Address5991 Seneca Street Elma NY
- SubdivisionBuffalo Crk Reservation
- CityElma
- CountyErie
- Zip Code14059
Similar Listings Nearby
- 23 Brookedge Road
Cheektowaga, NY$375,000
4.21 miles away
- 2005 Bowen Road
Elma, NY$369,900
2.53 miles away
- 1730 Billington Road
Elma, NY$349,999
3.76 miles away
- 75 Sherwood Lane
West Seneca, NY$349,900
3.09 miles away
- 369 Union Road
West Seneca, NY$349,900
3.44 miles away
- 50 Wedgewood Drive
West Seneca, NY$349,900
2.82 miles away
- 659 Quaker Road
Aurora, NY$349,900
4.77 miles away
- 228 Towers Boulevard
Cheektowaga, NY$339,900
4.30 miles away
- 1187 Borden Road
Cheektowaga, NY$329,900
4.43 miles away
- 125 Harvey Drive
Lancaster, NY$324,900
4.31 miles away
Listing courtesy of WNY Metro Roberts Realty,
© 2025 New York State Alliance of MLS’s NYSAMLS. Information deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. This site was last updated May-03-2025 3:35:54 pm.
© 2025 New York State Alliance of MLS’s NYSAMLS. Information deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. This site was last updated May-03-2025 3:35:54 pm.
5991 Seneca Street
Elma, NY
LIGHTBOX-IMAGES