Discover this move-in ready 3 bedroom, 2 full bath home perfectly situated on a spacious double corner lot, offering room to spread out both inside and out. With a brand new roof and newer windows throughout, peace of mind comes built in. Step inside to an inviting open floor plan that blends style and functionality. The kitchen is the heart of the home, featuring a large center island ideal for casual dining, entertaining, or family gatherings. The spiral staircase adds a striking architectural detail, leading to a private upstairs primary suite designed as your own retreat. Convenience meets practicality with first-floor laundry and a full basement for additional storage or hobby space. The property’s true standout is the detached 2-story garage, offering endless opportunities — create your dream workshop, a man cave, guest or in-law suite, or even finish it as an apartment for additional living space or rental income. This hidden gem offers the perfect balance of charm, updates, and versatility. With its generous lot, unique design features, and endless potential, this home is ready to welcome its next owners to enjoy, create, and make it their own. Square footage difference of 755 sq. ft., bringing it to a total of 1,689 sq. ft., was updated by an appraiser (see letter in attachments).
Property Details
Price:
$349,900
MLS #:
B1639703
Status:
Pending
Beds:
3
Baths:
2
Type:
Single Family
Subtype:
SingleFamilyResidence
Subdivision:
Diamond Sub
Neighborhood:
lancastervillage145203
Listed Date:
Sep 23, 2025
Finished Sq Ft:
1,689
Total Sq Ft:
1,689
Lot Size:
17,380 sqft / 0.40 acres (approx)
Year Built:
1927
See this Listing
Schools
School District:
Lancaster
Interior
Appliances
Dishwasher, Gas Oven, Gas Range, Gas Water Heater, Microwave, Refrigerator
Bathrooms
2 Full Bathrooms
Cooling
Central Air
Flooring
Carpet, Hardwood, Varies, Vinyl
Heating
Gas, Forced Air
Laundry Features
Main Level
Exterior
Architectural Style
Colonial, Two Story
Construction Materials
Vinyl Siding
Exterior Features
Concrete Driveway, Enclosed Porch, Fence, Porch
Parking Features
Detached, Garage
Financial
Taxes
$4,840
Map
Community
- Address86 Garfield Street Lancaster NY
- SubdivisionDiamond Sub
- CityLancaster
- CountyErie
- Zip Code14086
Subdivisions in Lancaster
- Autumn Park
- Autumnwood Sub
- Bellflower Village Condo
- Belltower Village Condo
- Belltower Village Condo A
- Blackstone Court
- Buffalo Crk Reservation
- Central Square Villas Con
- Cross Crk Sub
- Doe Haven Estates Ph 02
- Doe Haven Estates Ph I
- Fieldstream Estates
- Fieldstream/Forbes
- Fieldstream/Newport
- George Sub
- Glenridge Village Condo
- Glenridge Village Condo 0
- Hidden Mdw Sub-Ph 2
- Holland Land Co
- Holland Land Company’s Su
- Holland Land Companys
- Juniper Townhomes
- Lancaster
- Lancaster Terrace
- Palmer Heights Sub
- Palmer Hts Sub
- Pine Tree Farms
- Pinetree Farm
- Ridgecrest Condo
- Sandywood Circle
- Southpoint Div
- Town/Lancaster
- Village/Lancaster
Market Summary
Current real estate data for Single Family in Lancaster as of Mar 07, 2026
54
Single Family Listed
97
Avg DOM
231
Avg $ / SqFt
$404,928
Avg List Price
Property Summary
- Located in the Diamond Sub subdivision, 86 Garfield Street Lancaster NY is a Single Family for sale in Lancaster, NY, 14086. It is listed for $349,900 and features 3 beds, 2 baths, and has approximately 1,689 square feet of living space, and was originally constructed in 1927. The current price per square foot is $207. The average price per square foot for Single Family listings in Lancaster is $231. The average listing price for Single Family in Lancaster is $404,928. To schedule a showing of MLS#b1639703 at 86 Garfield Street in Lancaster, NY, contact your Concrete Jungle Realty agent at 3472420937.
Similar Listings Nearby
Courtesy of Howard Hanna WNY Inc.. Disclaimer: All data relating to real estate for sale on this page comes from the Broker Reciprocity (BR) of the New York State Alliance of MLSs. Detailed information about real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Concrete Jungle Realty include the name of the listing broker. Neither the listing company nor Concrete Jungle Realty shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. The Broker providing this data believes it to be correct, but advises interested parties to confirm any item before relying on it in a purchase decision. Copyright 2026. New York State Alliance of MLSs. All rights reserved. 86 Garfield Street
Lancaster, NY



