3622 Lakemont Himrod Road Milo NY 14842 MLS #R1578933

This remarkable property steeped in history and modern charm is Fully Furnished! Originally established in 1840 by John T. Smith as the Eagle Hotel, this iconic structure has long been a hub for travelers, originally serving as a stagecoach stop and later welcoming guests arriving by train. After the original building was destroyed by fire, it was rebuilt in 1946 and operated as the popular restaurant, The Eagle Hotel, for many years.
Approximately two years ago this magnificent property underwent a remarkable transformation, thoughtfully renovating it into two stunning apartments: a luxurious first-floor unit and a spacious second-floor residence. Apartment #1 features three bedrooms, two bathrooms, and an open floor plan with a chef’s kitchen—perfect for modern living and entertaining. Apartment #2 offers open concept living, dining and kitchen, and the four bedrooms and two bathrooms provide ample room for family and guests.
Included in this unique offering is a charming single-family home right next door. This residence features a large kitchen with a dining area, a comfortable living room, two bedrooms, and one and a half baths. The side porch is just perfect for enjoying those time when a bit of relaxation might be necessary. Between the two properties, a generous covered patio provides an ideal space for outdoor entertaining and barbecuing.
Located a few minutes from stunning Seneca Lake and nestled along the renowned Seneca Lake Wine Trail, this property offers immediate access to world-class wineries, outdoor recreation, and cultural attractions. Currently operating as successful short-term rentals with each unit bringing approximately $200 per night, these properties present an outstanding opportunity for continued income generation or mixed-use possibilities. This offering is a Fully Furnished turn – key opportunity!
This sale includes three tax map numbers and must be sold together. The two additional numbers are: 573089-099-028-0001-012-001-0000; 573089-099-028-0001-029-000-0000. 24 Hour notice for all showings. (Square footage is the combined number of square feet of the main building with two apartments and the single family home next door.)